{
  "dataset": {
    "workbook": "adventureworks_ai_tool_benchmark.xlsx",
    "sha256": "e790641e7c080df4fb63de63a1964154fdab3508a244e4200f25f75aef598108",
    "sales_rows": 56046,
    "return_rows": 1809,
    "note": "Public AdventureWorks sample data; no customer data."
  },
  "percentage_note": "Displayed rates and shares retain each tool's rounding.",
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "powerbi",
      "tool": "Power BI service",
      "date": "2026-11-10",
      "surface": "Browser; 60-day Power BI trial",
      "setup": "Original XLSX copied to SharePoint and loaded through Power Query. One missing territory relationship and text dates were repaired; calculations used DAX.",
      "output": "Monthly line chart, findings and PDF report.",
      "yearly_units": {
        "2015": 2630,
        "2016": 36230,
        "2017": 45314
      },
      "category_units_and_share": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units": 57809,
          "share_pct": 68.68
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units": 13929,
          "share_pct": 16.55
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units": 12436,
          "share_pct": 14.77
        },
        "Components": {
          "units": null,
          "share_pct": null
        }
      },
      "region_units": {
        "Australia": 17951,
        "Southwest": 17191,
        "Northwest": 12513,
        "Canada": 10894,
        "United Kingdom": 9694,
        "Germany": 7950,
        "France": 7862,
        "Southeast": 49,
        "Northeast": 40,
        "Central": 30
      },
      "category_return_rates": {
        "Bikes": {
          "units_sold": 13929,
          "units_returned": 429,
          "return_rate_pct": 3.08
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units_sold": 12436,
          "units_returned": 269,
          "return_rate_pct": 2.16
        },
        "Accessories": {
          "units_sold": 57809,
          "units_returned": 1130,
          "return_rate_pct": 1.95
        },
        "Components": {
          "units_sold": null,
          "units_returned": null,
          "return_rate_pct": null
        }
      },
      "monthly_units_2017": {
        "2017-01": 7020,
        "2017-02": 6828,
        "2017-03": 7327,
        "2017-04": 7680,
        "2017-05": 8199,
        "2017-06": 8260
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "tableau",
      "tool": "Tableau Public",
      "date": "2026-11-10",
      "surface": "Free web authoring",
      "setup": "Two relationships and text-date conversion were configured manually. Saving uses a public profile; the workbook was kept as an authoring session and the dashboard exported.",
      "output": "Monthly line chart, findings dashboard and PDF.",
      "yearly_units": {
        "2015": 2630,
        "2016": 36230,
        "2017": 45314
      },
      "category_units_and_share": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units": 57809,
          "share_pct": 68.68
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units": 13929,
          "share_pct": 16.55
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units": 12436,
          "share_pct": 14.77
        },
        "Components": {
          "units": null,
          "share_pct": null
        }
      },
      "region_units": {
        "Australia": 17951,
        "Canada": 10894,
        "Central": 30,
        "France": 7862,
        "Germany": 7950,
        "Northeast": 40,
        "Northwest": 12513,
        "Southeast": 49,
        "Southwest": 17191,
        "United Kingdom": 9694
      },
      "category_return_rates": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units_sold": 57809,
          "units_returned": 1130,
          "return_rate_pct": 1.955
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units_sold": 13929,
          "units_returned": 429,
          "return_rate_pct": 3.08
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units_sold": 12436,
          "units_returned": 269,
          "return_rate_pct": 2.163
        }
      },
      "monthly_units_2017": {
        "2017-01": 7020,
        "2017-02": 6828,
        "2017-03": 7327,
        "2017-04": 7680,
        "2017-05": 8199,
        "2017-06": 8260
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "qlik",
      "tool": "Qlik Cloud Analytics",
      "date": "2026-11-10",
      "surface": "Browser; 30-day Premium trial",
      "setup": "Suggested associations linked returns through regions rather than products. Eight load-script lines re-keyed the returns table.",
      "output": "Monthly bar chart, tables and a generated PDF saved separately from the download button.",
      "yearly_units": {
        "2015": 2630,
        "2016": 36230,
        "2017": 45314
      },
      "category_units_and_share": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units": 57809,
          "share_pct": 68.68
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units": 13929,
          "share_pct": 16.55
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units": 12436,
          "share_pct": 14.77
        },
        "Components": {
          "units": 0,
          "share_pct": 0.0
        }
      },
      "region_units": {
        "Australia": 17951,
        "Canada": 10894,
        "Central": 30,
        "France": 7862,
        "Germany": 7950,
        "Northeast": 40,
        "Northwest": 12513,
        "Southeast": 49,
        "Southwest": 17191,
        "United Kingdom": 9694
      },
      "category_return_rates": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units_sold": 57809,
          "units_returned": 1130,
          "return_rate_pct": 1.95
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units_sold": 13929,
          "units_returned": 429,
          "return_rate_pct": 3.08
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units_sold": 12436,
          "units_returned": 269,
          "return_rate_pct": 2.16
        },
        "Components": {
          "units_sold": 0,
          "units_returned": 0,
          "return_rate_pct": null
        }
      },
      "monthly_units_2017": {
        "2017-01": 7020,
        "2017-02": 6828,
        "2017-03": 7327,
        "2017-04": 7680,
        "2017-05": 8199,
        "2017-06": 8260
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "looker-studio",
      "tool": "Looker Studio",
      "date": "2026-11-10",
      "surface": "Free browser reporting",
      "setup": "Original XLSX loaded through the Excel connector. Two chart-level blends combined the sheets; monthly sorting and date grouping were configured.",
      "output": "Monthly bar chart, tables, findings and a two-page PDF.",
      "yearly_units": {
        "2015": 2630,
        "2016": 36230,
        "2017": 45314
      },
      "category_units_and_share": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units": 57809,
          "share_pct": 68.68
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units": 13929,
          "share_pct": 16.55
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units": 12436,
          "share_pct": 14.77
        }
      },
      "region_units": {
        "Australia": 17951,
        "Southwest": 17191,
        "Northwest": 12513,
        "Canada": 10894,
        "United Kingdom": 9694,
        "Germany": 7950,
        "France": 7862,
        "Southeast": 49,
        "Northeast": 40,
        "Central": 30
      },
      "category_return_rates": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units_sold": 57809,
          "units_returned": 1130,
          "return_rate_pct": 1.95
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units_sold": 13929,
          "units_returned": 429,
          "return_rate_pct": 3.08
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units_sold": 12436,
          "units_returned": 269,
          "return_rate_pct": 2.16
        }
      },
      "monthly_units_2017": {
        "2017-01": 7020,
        "2017-02": 6828,
        "2017-03": 7327,
        "2017-04": 7680,
        "2017-05": 8199,
        "2017-06": 8260
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "knime",
      "tool": "KNIME Analytics Platform",
      "date": "2026-11-10",
      "surface": "Free desktop application",
      "setup": "Reader, Joiner, date conversion, GroupBy and formula steps were configured manually. Category shares used the fixed total 84,174.",
      "output": "Line chart with row-number labels, PNG and return-rate CSV.",
      "yearly_units": {
        "2015": 2630,
        "2016": 36230,
        "2017": 45314
      },
      "category_units_and_share": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units": 57809,
          "share_pct": 68.678
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units": 13929,
          "share_pct": 16.548
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units": 12436,
          "share_pct": 14.774
        }
      },
      "region_units": {
        "Northwest": 12513,
        "Northeast": 40,
        "Central": 30,
        "Southwest": 17191,
        "Southeast": 49,
        "Canada": 10894,
        "France": 7862,
        "Germany": 7950,
        "Australia": 17951,
        "United Kingdom": 9694
      },
      "category_return_rates": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units_sold": 57809,
          "units_returned": 1130,
          "return_rate_pct": 1.954712933972219
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units_sold": 13929,
          "units_returned": 429,
          "return_rate_pct": 3.0799052336851176
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units_sold": 12436,
          "units_returned": 269,
          "return_rate_pct": 2.1630749437118046
        }
      },
      "monthly_units_2017": {
        "2017-01": 7020,
        "2017-02": 6828,
        "2017-03": 7327,
        "2017-04": 7680,
        "2017-05": 8199,
        "2017-06": 8260
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "python",
      "tool": "Python / pandas",
      "date": "2026-11-09",
      "surface": "Native script",
      "setup": "pandas imported the six sheets. The script checked keys, joined dimensions, aggregated sales and returns, and used a plotting library.",
      "output": "Monthly chart and five answer CSVs.",
      "yearly_units": {
        "2015": 2630,
        "2016": 36230,
        "2017": 45314
      },
      "category_units_and_share": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units": 57809,
          "share_pct": 68.67797657233825
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units": 13929,
          "share_pct": 16.54786513650296
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units": 12436,
          "share_pct": 14.77415829115879
        }
      },
      "region_units": {
        "Australia": 17951,
        "Canada": 10894,
        "Central": 30,
        "France": 7862,
        "Germany": 7950,
        "Northeast": 40,
        "Northwest": 12513,
        "Southeast": 49,
        "Southwest": 17191,
        "United Kingdom": 9694
      },
      "category_return_rates": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units_sold": 57809,
          "units_returned": 1130,
          "return_rate_pct": 1.954712933972219
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units_sold": 13929,
          "units_returned": 429,
          "return_rate_pct": 3.0799052336851176
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units_sold": 12436,
          "units_returned": 269,
          "return_rate_pct": 2.1630749437118046
        }
      },
      "monthly_units_2017": {
        "2017-01": 7020,
        "2017-02": 6828,
        "2017-03": 7327,
        "2017-04": 7680,
        "2017-05": 8199,
        "2017-06": 8260
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "r",
      "tool": "R",
      "date": "2026-11-09",
      "surface": "Native script",
      "setup": "readxl imported the workbook; the R script joined dimensions, aggregated sales and returns, and plotted the monthly series.",
      "output": "Monthly chart and five answer CSVs.",
      "yearly_units": {
        "2015": 2630,
        "2016": 36230,
        "2017": 45314
      },
      "category_units_and_share": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units": 57809,
          "share_pct": 68.67797657233825
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units": 13929,
          "share_pct": 16.54786513650296
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units": 12436,
          "share_pct": 14.77415829115879
        }
      },
      "region_units": {
        "Australia": 17951,
        "Canada": 10894,
        "Central": 30,
        "France": 7862,
        "Germany": 7950,
        "Northeast": 40,
        "Northwest": 12513,
        "Southeast": 49,
        "Southwest": 17191,
        "United Kingdom": 9694
      },
      "category_return_rates": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units_sold": 57809,
          "units_returned": 1130,
          "return_rate_pct": 1.954712933972219
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units_sold": 13929,
          "units_returned": 429,
          "return_rate_pct": 3.079905233685118
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units_sold": 12436,
          "units_returned": 269,
          "return_rate_pct": 2.163074943711805
        }
      },
      "monthly_units_2017": {
        "2017-01": 7020,
        "2017-02": 6828,
        "2017-03": 7327,
        "2017-04": 7680,
        "2017-05": 8199,
        "2017-06": 8260
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "sql",
      "tool": "DuckDB SQL",
      "date": "2026-11-09",
      "surface": "Native SQL engine",
      "setup": "Python imported the original workbook into six DuckDB tables. SQL performed the business calculations.",
      "output": "Monthly table and answer CSVs; charting is a separate step.",
      "yearly_units": {
        "2015": 2630.0,
        "2016": 36230.0,
        "2017": 45314.0
      },
      "category_units_and_share": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units": 57809.0,
          "share_pct": 68.6779765723
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units": 13929.0,
          "share_pct": 16.5478651365
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units": 12436.0,
          "share_pct": 14.7741582912
        }
      },
      "region_units": {
        "Australia": 17951.0,
        "Canada": 10894.0,
        "Central": 30.0,
        "France": 7862.0,
        "Germany": 7950.0,
        "Northeast": 40.0,
        "Northwest": 12513.0,
        "Southeast": 49.0,
        "Southwest": 17191.0,
        "United Kingdom": 9694.0
      },
      "category_return_rates": {
        "Accessories": {
          "units_sold": 57809.0,
          "units_returned": 1130.0,
          "return_rate_pct": 1.954712934
        },
        "Bikes": {
          "units_sold": 13929.0,
          "units_returned": 429.0,
          "return_rate_pct": 3.0799052337
        },
        "Clothing": {
          "units_sold": 12436.0,
          "units_returned": 269.0,
          "return_rate_pct": 2.1630749437
        }
      },
      "monthly_units_2017": {
        "2017-01": 7020.0,
        "2017-02": 6828.0,
        "2017-03": 7327.0,
        "2017-04": 7680.0,
        "2017-05": 8199.0,
        "2017-06": 8260.0
      }
    }
  ]
}
